Customer Reviews
A clear view. 
2008-07-25
If you want great resolution, here it is.
Lots of extras too. Don't expect any
surprises here, Paul controls the content,
start to finish.
The commentaries are still enlightening.
DVD a must have for McCartney fans 
2008-07-09
A very excellent DVD of McCartney, showing live clips of his performances with Wings, and other scenes. The DVD quality is excellent, and it shows the brilliance and sagacious insight of the quality of his music. A must have for all McCartney fans.
DVD Packaging 2008-07-07
Hi,
I bought this "new" and sealed from eBay, from a shipper in Thailand, and each of the 3 discs were encased in a sleeve (inside the box) and there was no insert of any kind in the box (i.e. booklet).
Can anyone confirm if this is the official packaging or some cheap knock-off I bought?
The McCartney Years 2008-06-04
This video is a excellent compulation of Paul McCartney concerts and videos through out his solo years. Including his time with wings and after. I throughly enjoyed it. If you're a big McCartney fan this is a must own.
Historic! 2008-06-03
This three disc set covers over forty years of Paul McCartney and Wings with studio video, live performances and extras that you probably have never seen. All the songs have been cleaned up and most are in 5.1 surround sound. Paul also contributes valuable and interesting voice-over commentaries for much of the material, if selected.
Don't let the first disc fool you into thinking that all the videos will be the same. Some of the storylines and video may be a bit dated looking and fuzzy, but the sound is perfect. "Ebony & Ivory" is a bit saccharin for my tastes, but Mac makes up for that with great video renditions of, "Mamunia", "Maybe I'm Amazed", "Mull Of Kintyre" and of all things, "C-Moon", which sounds great.
The second disc covers videos of Paul's work in the eighties and nineties with crisper videos and great sound. There is new life breathed into, "Pipes Of Peace" and "Fine Line". It's a nice grouping of songs that were not as popular as the Wings ear, but just as creative and important. This disc also has interesting extras, including the documentary, "Creating Chaos At Abbey Road", which is not to be missed.
The third disc is much better in visual clarity and covers seven songs from the seventies with the classic "Wings" performing in fantastic form with great sound and a spectacular light show. The second `unplugged' section with studio musicians in a small theater is perfect with the amazing dexterity and clarity from an acoustic performance. Paul and band mates perform four gems here. This is followed by the concert at Glastonbury, which looked like an amazing event with Paul performing nearly a dozen songs, including great renditions of, "Let Me Roll It", "Flaming Pie", "Hey Jude" and a mournful, Yesterday".
The extras on this disc are great with Paul's "Live Aid" contribution of "Let It Be" and friends. Paul overdubs the problems with sound and how there was no rehearsal or sound check. The sign of a true professional. Superbowl XXXIX is a visual and sound-ful knockout with - "Baby You Can Drive My Car", "Back In The U.S.S.R.", "Live & Let Die" and closing with, "Hey Jude". The crowd is completely taken with him.
Paul is alive and although this collection is exhaustive, he shows no sign of slowing down his recording of marvelous material. Don't forget about the extensive booklet, either!
Great DVD! 2008-05-22
It's rather incredible to ponder the fact that with the release of
The McCartney Years in late 2007, Paul McCartney has now been making recordings in various mediums for the better part of 40 years--and that's not even including the decade he spent as a member of the world's greatest band. And while some may quibble about certain details of the content and presentation, this three-disc set, packed with videos, concert footage, interviews, documentaries, and more, will surely satisfy the vast majority of Sir Paul's loyal subjects. The dozens of videos, occupying the first two discs and spanning the years from 1970 ("Maybe I'm Amazed," ten years before the emergence of MTV) to 2005 ("Fine Line"), can be viewed in either chronological order or as programmed by Macca himself. Ranging from straight lip-synced performances to various conceptual films, they are a decidedly mixed bag. In some cases (e.g. "London Town"), the songs are superior to the clips, while in others, the reverse is true ("Coming Up," a lightweight tune but a delightful video in which McCartney portrays everyone from Buddy Holly to Sparks keyboardist Ron Mael). Sometimes both the song and the video are terrific ("Take it Away" features Ringo Starr on drums, producer George Martin on piano, and a cameo by actor John Hurt; "Band on the Run," a creative pastiche of photos, film effects, and other media, suggests that the band in question was the Beatles, not Wings), while some fail on both counts (John Lennon might have had the likes of "C-Moon" in mind when he referred to McCartney's '70s output as "all pizza and fairytales"). Of the three concerts included on Volume Three, the best (and shortest) comes from a 1991
Unplugged show and features lovely versions of "Every Night" and "And I Love Her";
Rockshow spotlights Wings on tour in '76, and the 2004 gig in Glastonbury, England features McCartney's excellent current band (a good show, but the playlist isn't nearly as adventurous as, say, 2005's
Live in Red Square). Extras include McCartney's commentary on several of the videos; footage from Live Aid in '85 and the Super Bowl in '02; and, accompanying every DVD menu, various raw and unreleased live and studio performances of obscurities like "Blackpool." The late Linda McCartney is featured throughout, of course, and if
The McCartney Years is a
de facto tribute to his first wife, as one reviewer has suggested, it's a more than fitting one.
--Sam Graham
Great Videos! 2008-05-17
Great videos. It shows all the evolution of Macca's career. The only bad point is that it do not cointains the Chaos and Creation in Abbey Road show, just the making of.
Amazing complete collection of McCartney videos 2008-05-17
I've never seen most of these videos even though I'm a great Beatle fan. The sound and the 5.1 surround mixes are excellent. The videos are fun, interesting and much better than I expected. A great entertainment value and highly recommended!
Barely worth the asking price 
2008-05-13
For someone who hasn't seen (or heard) all of Sir Paul's hit solo records, this would be a good sampler. However, if you already have most of his albums (or seen these videos before) this compilation would not be of interest. One reason is that many of the videos are hard to watch because of irrelevant content quickly cut together into a blur of images having little to do with the song. My biggest problem is that the picture quality leaves much to be desired: it's dark and fuzzy with faded colors. The sound is OK, but all of these should have been remastered for such an ambitious collection. An example of this is the 'Eleanor Rigby' segment from "Give My Regards to Broadstreet" movie. It looks and sounds much better on the original movie DVD, if you already have it. There are a couple of nice interviews, and the commentary tracks give a bit of extra insight, but you can tell that not a lot of money was spent on this production.
Paul McCartney,,,The Real King of Rock & Roll 2008-04-30
I have been a Beatles and McCartney fan from the very start.
Myself being a Rock/Blues Guitarist and Singer....Paul greatly influenced my style in every way.
This video is a great joy...just like Paul. :)
Cheers,
Ken Widlake
