Whats wrong with the fifth hp book.
Author: Roxy Chick
From: Brisbane, Australia
Age: 13
Date: 31st Aug 2004, 9:32 AM
Rating: 3
Comment:
Title: Whats wrong with the fifth hp book.
Well, where do I start?
The first time i read the fifth book was last year and i read it in 2 days. I loved it! But i was reading it 24/7.
I read it again a year later and i thought it was totally bad. Why did Sirius have to die? Why is Harry so angry? Why didn't anyone believe Dumbledore? How can the school just completely go wild and the twins fly out the window. That was the most unrealistic. Why didn't Harry and Cho actually DO anything! Their should have been more relationships. These series need to mature a bit. Little kids aren't going to look at a book with 700 pages. So how will they know whats in it? Can't it be a G rated relationship 16 year olds r gonna have relationships, their not going to sit around talking about cartoons their going to talk about boys and girls. Harry and Ron should talk about girls and Hermione should talk about boys or just go out with Harry or Ron. Everyone knows their going to get together(by the way 3rd movie loved it! I jumped twice and i hid when the dementor opened it's mouth. It just looked wrong.) Harry and cho should have done things instead of break up hopelessly and Harry and Hermione were so flirting. Hermione is meant to be ugly in the book yet she's pretty in the movie. If the books grow up a bit more and get realistic the 6th one should be a hit but from what I can see, the fith ism just bombing!
A Storyteller Topic - Harry Potter Book and Movie Reviews
The Harry Potter books by JK Rowling have been a hit with children and adults around the world. You've read the books and seen the movies, now share your opinion with the world and write a review.
Read the latest Harry Potter Book and Movie Reviews
Read past Harry Potter Book and Movie Reviews
Write your own Harry Potter Book and Movie Review
| GETTING AROUND | |
 |
Home |
|
|
Kids Activities |
|
|
Special Needs Corner |
|
|
Special Needs Software |
|
|
Learning Resource |
|
|
Educational Books |
|
|
Educational Toys |
| Learning Resources | |
|
Useful & Practical Ideas |
|
|
|
Learning Disabilities |
|
|
ADHD |
|
|
Learn to Spell |
|
|
Learn to Read |
|
|
Learn to Write |
|
|
Learn Mathematics |
|
|
Practical ideas |
| Kids Activities | |
|
|
Children's Stories |
|
|
Kids Art |
|
|
Scrambler |
|
|
Automaths |
|
|
Math Games |
|
|
Base Ten Count |
|
|
Mega Scrambler |
|
|
Print Activities |
|
|
Harry Potter |
|
|
Pokemon |
 |
Recommend this page |
|
|
Links |
|
|
Feedback |
|
|
Privacy policy |
|
|
About us |
|
|
Famous Artists |
|
|
|
|
|
Kids Fun |
Copyright © 1997 - 2007 Education by Design. All rights reserved. |